Uh you can close this, It was kind of dumb xD

I'm thankful that you feel that way pal :).

I too am thinking of leaving myself because of that attitude as well.

Guys, there's no need for this kind of drama. No one insulted anyone, there was no "disrespect" or "attitude", people just had their own critique. TRUE_AMERICAN_GODZILLA you've been supplying fantastic posts to this forum for a long time (it'd be a huge loss if you left), just cuz a few of them haven't gotten so well, doesn't mean you suck, or people don't like it, etc. We all have those discussions that just don't go that well. 

I'm sorry if you see this as drama, but that was just plain out disrespectful to shoot down his ideas like that, and say they aren't good? how about constructive criticism? Where i come from that's what people are about. Not berating others for their different views or outtakes on things.

I'm assuming you're talking about Gman (the non-moderator one)? This was at the end of his last post on that discussion;

"I don't wanna see such backlash against your idea just because it can't be considered Godzilla. Just remember that, okay? It's a good idea with potential, but it must be used cautiously. Try it. I'm sure it'd have a great home elsewhere, but not as part of Godzilla, unfortunately."

Sounds like constructive criticism to me.

mmmm no, was refering to this line more like it.

but not as part of Godzilla, unfortunately.

That my good sir, is what irked me. Y'all over here can have your opinions, but who are you to say his idea isn't worthy of being part of Godzilla? Oh right, no one. I said my piece, and i'm done.

He asked people their opinion on the matter and people told him. There was no ill intent or drama, he asked if the people on this forum wanted to see a realistic take on Godzilla and some people told him no, it was that simple, there's no need to apologize for giving my opinion to a thread asking how I felt about the matter. I could see if I was harsh or insulting, but no one on that thread was.

I don't think you understand what he was trying to say. All I know is, there wasn't a single point where I felt he was insulting anything. Only legit criticism, just cuz someone doesn't 100% approve of something doesn't mean they are disrespectful. The point of criticism is to help you improve, it's just as important as the work itself sometimes.

no one whas insulting anyone, its yust that everyone has a difrent opinion, and plese american godzilla and gorilla godzilla don't leve

 I could see if I was harsh or insulting

There's no need for that shit! you don't like his idea...so you are harsh and insulting? hmm...logic i guess.

Guys, this is a case of making something out of nothing. I just skimmed through much that thread and from what I can tell he did indeed ask for people's opinions. They gave him their opinion. He defended his. Others defended theres. Now I'm not entirely sure why he felt the need to end his tenure in that thread, there was no flamming or direct disrespect, just normal, by-the-numbers, jagged, fan debate.

This is a franchise fandom fellas. People are going to disagree on things and they're going to disagree very passionately. Buck up. There was no remark in there that directly insulted True American Godzilla and he didn't directly insult anyone else. It was simply a heated debate-- And if you can't take the heat... run.

Wait what? I clearly said no one was harsh or insulting, please use the whole phrase rather than cutting around it to make it seem like something else was said.

 there's no need to apologize for giving my opinion to a thread asking how I felt about the matter. I could see if I was harsh or insulting, but no one on that thread was.

Pretty obvious what you said, but alrighty.

but, i do not care at the moment. What some said was insulting enough to TAG's post, that he felt the need to get them closed. Not only that thread either, i've seen that kind of stuff in previous threads and it's borderline ridiculous.

Tryna raise my 2 year old in a world where this kind of stuff isn't prevelant, and i get to an online community i thought i would like only to see that same thing? no thank you.

Carnosaur,
You misread, he said "I could see if I was harsh or insulting" as in, he could understand the need to apologize if he were harsh or insulting.

Guys just quit fighting. It's over now.

And here I thought the days of fighting and arguing were over here on the Godzilla forums. Huh.

@Carnosaur

Dude, there have been threads leading members to be way more 'harsh and insulting' than that one. (In my opinion, nobody had been in it, but that's just me, I guess). Trust me, I've seen them. So that was really nothing.

@True American Godzilla

Don't leave just for that one thread, man

Excuse me, I meant to put a period at the end of that sentence. Can't now.

Lol u didn't have to mention u forgot a period.

@Carnosaur

Dude, there have been threads leading members to be way more 'harsh and insulting' than that one. (In my opinion, nobody had been in it, but that's just me, I guess). Trust me, I've seen them. So that was really nothing.

Ah, i've seen them and i'm tired of reading them. Ain't no need for it!

@Carnosaur

As am I, which is why I said I thought the days of fighting and arguing on here were over and was disappointed to see it yet again. I just mean that you shouldn't get that offended over that post since it was nothing compared to some threads from the past.

There wasn't any fighting on this forum. As I said it was simply disagreeing. This is like if I made a thread saying "Do you think Ebirah is awesome?" then saying that I do and after people say they don't making a thread telling people that they weren't respecting my opinion.

It's honestly been extremely blown out of proportion by gorillagodzilla. If you look on the actual thread in question there was nothing wrong with the responses and it was completely civil, to me it seemed like it got closed because true american godzilla realized most people wouldn't see the realistic godzilla as a true representation.

@Durp004

I agree with you 100%. I didn't really mean the disagreements, I meant people fighting BECAUSE they disagreed. AKA Carnosaur and Gorillagodzilla getting offended because people didn't agree with True American Godzilla, then making a big deal about it.

Also, when I saw this thread, I was thinking, "Oh, man, what happened?" And was shocked to see that really nothing offensive HAD occurred.

It's ironic because gorillagodzilla also disagreed with the original post. Seems like he was leaving the forum and wanted to make a big thread beforehand

Yeah, I just noticed that....

@GORILLAGODZILLA77897

"He has a right to contribute his own and you guys are shooting it down"

I dont want to start another fight with you but I hope I also have that right, because you shot me down when I gave my Zilla opinion. 

To All Forum Members:

Why can't we all just respect eachothers opinions, most people here on the forums are good people, all the people I know on the forums respect everyones opinion but they are some that arent that nice. Like I said all the people I know respectful but I do know that sone people I dont know that arent as nice as the members I know. I hope we dont have a "T Rex vs Spino" argument where we dont respect eachother. I might think about leaving Godzilla forums and moving to JW Forums if this continues. I myself didnt see too many bad comments in True American Godzillas topic but there are still people who dont seen to respect peoples opinions on different things. (NOT POINTING FINGERS)

I guess I must prepare for incoming hate.

@Godzilla316

Very well said. And don't worry, I think the discussion is over so you won't get any hate.

But I hope you decide not to leave. I think leaving is the problem. In fact, I'm going to write a post about it in a sec. But we NEED nice people, and leaving, I fear, will make everything worse.

@Godzilla316 We do respect each others' opinion around here for the most part. For example, I didn't agree with the justification True American Godzilla gave for why his idea would work, but instead of simply complain about it, I tried giving some constructive criticism on how he could use that idea, and some other stuff about portraying unrealistic characters in realistic settings and whatnot :P

I don't think he was talking about you necessarily, TheGman123.

@DINOZILLA439

Dont worry I wont leave anytime soon, although I do make daily visits to the JW Forums.