Godzilla Minus One 2, Supernova and Monarch news

Why Ford's Character Suffers in Godzilla (2014)! (Does Ford's Character Suck?)

Pinned Topic16916 Views29 Replies
Forum Topic

InstinctiveGigan

MemberMothra LarvaeOct-06-2014 4:31 AM

“InstinctiveGigan, why are you making more topics about the flaws of Godzilla (2014)? The film has already been out on DVD for nearly a month, why continually talk crap about it?”

Personally, I believe a film can never get too old to discuss its flaws. I can go on and on about the flaws I feel Heisei films like SpaceGodzilla or Destroyah have, but just because they are over 2 decades old, doesn’t mean I can never talk about said flaws.

This particular discussion is going to focus on the character of Ford, and why his character arc suffered magnificently in the film, thus, making the film suffer since he’s our main focus. Let’s get this out of the way, is Ford a bland character? Kinda. And no, having a dark backstory or “potential” to be an intricate character is not a good excuse for how he is portrayed in the film. That’s like saying Spider-man deserves my love and attention just from his Uncle Ben dying, not his personality or where his morality stands etc., just the fact he’s got a dead uncle.

And for those of you worried I’m gonna hate on your favorite Godzilla film cuz I’m a jerk, don’t worry. I’m solely talking about Ford and how the film giving him the main focus was a huge mistake. Surely, we can all agree on that being a negative of the film. And before anyone mentions it, yes, I do hear in the movie novelization Ford gets more character due to us getting more inside his head, but that does not excuse the movie for not characterizing him in the actual film just like it doesn’t excuse Destiny’s lack of lore by making it readable on Bungie.net.

And just remember, I'm not a hater that wants to crap on this film and make it garbage in everyone's eyes. I'm just a concerned fan that wants to help fix what is otherwise a very huge, glaring problem that I hope isn't repeated in the sequels. So, with that said, let’s take an in-depth look on why the character of Ford Brody in “Godzilla (2014)”, more or less, sucks.

______________________________________________________________________________________

Let’s go step-by-step:

1) His Actions And Presence Are Meaningless

If Ford were removed from the film altogether, what would be different from the main storyline? If every other soldier in the film were portrayed realistically, absolutely nothing. There’s a review for the film that helped inspire me to start this discussion that puts it best. The nuke story towards the end was only fabricated to give Ford a reason to be there. I mean think about it, realistically the soldiers would be the ones to push that auto-pilot button on the boat to get the nuke out already, not just Ford. The soldiers should also be concerned about the Muto’s nest and hang back to take care of it, not just Ford. There should be more than one freaking bomb expert on that mission in the entirety of the U.S. that could help with the retrieval/detonation plan, not just Ford. It’s like you had to make the other military members complete dumbasses to give him a point, and if your character has no point in a story than get him out of there, don’t contrive the story to give him a reason to be there; which Godzilla (2014) unfortunately did.

So just to cover it all, Ford’s only bearing on the events of the story is killing the Muto’s nest, and sending the nuke away on the boat. And both could’ve and should’ve been done by the other soldiers, the only point Ford has in the story and they have to make the other soldiers complete idiots for it to work. Replace Ford with “random American soldier with an actual brain #6” and he can be written out of the story completely.

2) He Is A SUPER Contrived Character

What is contrivance? Something that happens for no other reason than to serve the plot, like everything Ford does or experiences. Like telling his family to stay in San Francisco even though he’s aware giant monsters are converging there, which no good father would do. Or being unable to open the nuke at the end even though he should have tools or something that should help him deal with this situation, forcing the soldiers to take it to the boat. Or how every other nuke expert in the entire world just conveniently vanished into thin air, leaving only him to deal with this Godzilla epidemic. Or how he’s the only soldier in the train escort that survived. Or how even though the military specifically said they wouldn’t be able to extract him even though mere seconds after the EMP wears out, they send a chopper to rescue him anyway. Do you see the problem?

Now contrivance isn’t a bad thing, because if something out of the ordinary doesn’t happen than you have no story, so in other words, no Godzilla and no Mutos. But when it’s obvious and borderline stupid, that’s when you can see contrivance out in the open, naked. The job of a good writer is to clothe contrivance up and make it blend into the background. But a lazy writer will use contrivance to move the story along because they don’t want to bother to think of better ways to put their characters in the situations of the story. You might think I’m looking into too much stuff in terms of what Ford goes through, but how many of you didn’t automatically know when Ford pulled his gun out at the female Muto at the end that Godzilla was going to save him? With everything coincidently happening to Ford this massively, I’m surprised Ford isn’t a “chosen one” in a “prophecy” that is “destined” to help Godzilla defeat the Mutos.

3) Ford Doesn't Interact with Anyone

Remember when Ford was interacting with his wife and his dad at the beginning of the movie, remember how fleshed out his character was becoming? Well, after Cranston dad dies, say goodbye to that because we are literally given no other instance where Ford’s character is built. We don’t see him make any new friends on the way, we don’t see him morally/emotionally struggle. I mean there was that one phone call he made to his wife and that one time he looked at a picture of his family, that was, something. Heck, it seems like we were starting to get something with that Japanese kid in Hawaii, but by the end of the scene the kid vanished from the movie completely and feels more like that kid was just put into the film for a helpless boy Ford had to save so the audience can view him as a “hero”. If Ford developed friendships with Serizawa or the other military soldiers on his journey, we would constantly see his character being fleshed out more, but we never get that.

Instead, it’s like the film expects the first hour of development Ford got to be enough for us to care about him and become invested, that’s unfortunately not how it works. You have to continually prove to us why this guy we’re continually watching is so awesome. As audience members, we aren’t gonna take your word for it. In other words show, don’t tell. And this fact is probably going to bite the sequel in the ass too, because if Max Borenstein thinks Ford was characterized plenty in this film, than he’s probably going to think writing Ford (if he returns) with little interactions in the sequel will be good enough cuz “the original covered it”.

4) Other Characters Are So Much More Interesting

Serizawa is a scientist that has studied monsters for years, has a clear dark past, and has a clear enough understanding and passion for these beasts that he actually mourns over the possible death of Godzilla toward the end of the film. Admiral William, is a strong military leader who wants to save innocent people and has a clear struggle on whether or not he should let nature take its course like Serizawa says yet risk massive collateral damage or use his own forces in a desperate attempt to save everyone. Heck, even Ford’s wife Ellie is a mother who desperately wants to save her child but is forced to care for people in a time where goliaths are at war and risk her safety and her child’s for the safety and protection of others.

The main point is that, although Ford has the potential to be interesting to follow, for this particular story he’s not. Yet we have other characters that clearly can be a million times more interesting to watch during this story but we fail to focus on because the writers think Ford is just such a lovable guy. Comparing how interesting the other charactesr in the story are just makes his character look all the more bland by comparison. Serizawa still interests me after watching the film 6 times far more than Ford ever did, which is why I hope the sequel focuses on him instead. Because if you cut away from a Godzilla fight in the sequel to focus on Serizawa discussing monster conspiracy or his past, it’s less of a sting, but if you cut away to Ford buying a Snickers from a 7-11 I will lose my freaking mind!

 

______________________________________________________________________________________

And that’s pretty much all my points for why Ford alone is a massive negative for this film. I feel if we were following Serizawa, or even Ellie, or you know, Joe Brody the film would’ve been 10x better since the human element would be worth the cuts away from Godzilla fights. And I hope the writer(s) learn from their mistakes, whether that’s characterizing Ford more or focusing on a much more interesting person in the story, the sequel will be better for it. And again, I’m not saying Ford is a bad character, as mentioned before he does have potential and there are segments of the story where it shows you he could be interesting (mainly in the first hour). But, the film is trying to convince me he’s interesting by just saying he is, and not showing it. Again, show, don’t tell.

I hope this advice is followed, because I do want the human element to thrive in this franchise. After all, we love Dr. Grant from “Jurassic Park” and (ironic enough) Brody from “Jaws”, make us love Ford from the Legendary Godzilla franchise. And if not, there’s this other cool character that is way more interesting and cool to follow and focus on, just a small character that plays not too big a role, you know, a certain, fun guy called GODZILLA!

Welp, those are my thoughts. I sure hope a lot of people reply to this discussion otherwise I’ve spent over an hour dedicating my super nerd brain to this long typed piece of thought for nothing. What do you guys think? Do you agree with me about Ford? How would you improve him or the human element of this new franchise? Leave your thoughts, and thanks for patiently reading this! I appreciate it!

(Also, if I have any spelling/grammar errors, please let me know. I’m super OCD about that kind of stuff and it’s super late and I wanna go to bed cuz I have no life and BAH!)

User Avatar
Sci-Fi King25
Group: Member
Rank: Gigan
View Profile

This was very well written Gigan! I agree; Ford was really boring and emotionless in the film. I wouldn't mind seeing him in the sequel, but only if he was better written.

“Banana oil.”- George Takei, Gigantis: The Fire Monster

User Avatar
Panthalassan
Group: Member
Rank: Mothra Larvae
View Profile

Great insights IG! I think part of the problem comes with killing off Joe Brody. They had set up a relationship that needed to be repaired, and should've tried to make that one of the arcs of the movie. Ford starts off estranged from his father, perhaps blames him for surviving when his mother doesnt, and through this adventure the two of them reconcile. Because really, the only other arc we have is the "I just wanna get home to my family", which is just not enough. We know he's gonna make it; what, is his family gonna die? Is he not gonna make it back to San Francisco? The stakes just aren't that high.

And you're absolutely right about him not interacting with anyone. Perhaps they wanted him to be more of a blank slate, more of an avatar for the audience to see the movie through. But maybe situations like the bridge scene with the MUTO or with the nuke in SF could've had more tension with some additional character interactions; arguing with the soldiers about the nuke, joking with the soldiers on the train; something to help us feel like these are real people with real lives.

User Avatar
Panthalassan
Group: Member
Rank: Mothra Larvae
View Profile

Also yes about the contrivance bit, you could almost say that in this movie, without Ford the whole world would've been destroyed. The soldiers just forgot about that nest! The nuke blowing up 20 miles offshore certainly wasn't going to take care of that problem.

I'm just realizing now, they had a goldmine of tension there. "Should we leave the nuke and destroy the nest, but as collateral ourselves and san francisco? Or should we move it and hope we find a way to deal with the 10000 baby mutos?" Missed opportunity. 

But anyways. Ford ended up being savior of Godzilla (by distracting the mother muto, blowing up her nest), savior of San Francisco (my setting that nuke carrying boat out to sea) and savior of humanity (by eliminating probably extinction in destroying the nest). Part of this I believe has to do with the insistence that we see these monsters from characters' perspectives; they wanted a more subjective movie and that means they had to stretch believability by putting the characters physically in the middle of every big event. Admirable to adhere to a set philosophy, but in this case it is actually to a fault.

User Avatar
Panthalassan
Group: Member
Rank: Mothra Larvae
View Profile

That said, I would be happy to see Ford down the line as a grizzled nuke expert with "experience dealing with MUTOs", maybe more of a supporting/cameo role.

User Avatar
Smaugzilla
Group: Member
Rank: Mothra Larvae
View Profile

In a nut shell, I think the character of Ford Brody was somewhat undeveloped to put it diplomatically. There could have been a great deal more to his character. I would also like to point out that I'm not against Aaron Taylor-Johnson; I personally think he is a good actor, and he is still young so there is plenty of time for him to develop his skills. At the end of the day he is given a script and he has to adhere to it, even if he had the same facial expression throughout most of the film; one of bewilderment and uncertainty! lol 

 

User Avatar
Jamaal
Group: Member
Rank: Mothra Larvae
View Profile

With time, Taylor-Johnson's Ford Brody has grown in terms of appreciation with me. He's not the typical over-the-top action hero who's the main protagonist. He does heroic things, but they're understated, as is his performance. There are no great speeches, no dramatic pronouncements. Rather, we have a military man, a husband and father, a son who's lost both parents, confronted by answers to things that no one can comprehend. Lt. Ford seems stunned, a bit dazed, even when having to get about the business of finding and disarming a nuclear weapon mere blocks away from where giant monsters are fighting.  

This understatedness makes it easy to follow him on his journey across the Pacific. And Godzilla is a 'journey' film: you travel with it narrative-wise, and follow it, physically, from Japan to the American West Coast.

Taylor-Johnson's Lt.Ford is, for me, a character within reach, plausible enough to identify with and root for.

User Avatar
Durp004
Group: Member
Rank: Baragon
View Profile

I agree with Jamaal to some extent. Ford is very low key in the things he does. That makes his logical for the most part, but not necessarily human. 

 

The fact is the MUTOs havee ruined Fords life, they killed his mother, which in turn caused him to have a strained relationship with his father thinking he is a madman for most of his life. Then only after realizing his father was right all along, he dies as well. Now the MUTOs are endangering his wife and child with their nest in the city. Ford doesn't really ever seem like he has a personal vendetta against the MUTOs though. He destroyed the nest not because he wanted revenge but just because it was logical. I would have liked some fleshed out instances that make it clear how much he hates the MUTOs, how much they've done to ruin his life, and how much they threaten everything he has left, for all the time the MUTOs get it and the amount of times Ford runs into them directly, there could have been something. Literally right after it kills his dad he runs into it again and there's no sense of hatred there. I mean literally within probably 12 hours of his dad dying he sees it, and there's nothing. He could want to go to San Francisco to save his family but it could be made clear he has some underlying want to actually stop these monsters.

Jut really wasted potential to me that something like that wasn't ever really shown.

User Avatar
SuperZillaRealms
Group: Member
Rank: Mothra Larvae
View Profile

I know some others said this but Ford is very uninteresting, he didn’t have any development nor did he have a completed story arc (if he had one in the first place). Elle is there as a damsel in distress and to be honest it feels like the kid is just there to make us want Ford to come back alive. I still like these characters but not as much as the characters from Godzilla X Mechagodzilla. King Of The Monsters may be different because Michael Dougherty said that he was trying to make us love the characters while balancing the monster action. But overall the MonsterVerse so far has mostly underdeveloped characters. If you want a real feel for these characters then I recommended reading the official movie novelizations.

"The Bigger They Are, The Harder You Fight"

User Avatar
Artemisace
Group: Member
Rank: Mothra Larvae
View Profile

While I agree with some of what's being said here I also disagree with it at points. While I will never argue that Ford got "enough" character development, I think he got what he needed for the story. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like some on here would have liked to have seen a more archetypal heroes journey for Ford. But I don't think that was the arc they ever had intended for him. Ford Brody goes through just enough character development to give us a sense of who he is. Pardon the following synopsis. When he is young we see he loves his parents and is disappointed that he can't surprise his father with the sign that he made him. Then when the nuclear plant is being destroyed we see how it terrifies him and we can relate because we would all be in the same frame of mind watching our parents place of work be destroyed. Cut to Lt. Brody EOD tech and US Navy... I think it's not ever really stated. Or I missed it. Either way he is asked if has family waiting for him and he says I hope so, meaning he is hoping that his family is there and he can come back to a normal life. But also having seen what we just saw it also hints at a possible underlying worry that he will be left alone again. We see how much he loves his wife and child and get a pretty good scene of them together in my opinion then he's off to Japan. With his father he finally comes to the realization that he can't keep running from what has happened and we get a hint that he doesn't like destruction, he specifically tells his dad that his job is stopping bombs not blowing them up.

When in Japan, he starts to reconnect with his father and encounters his past both mentally and physically. Then when the male MUTO escapes and Joe Brody dies, we get a call to action for him that he refuses. instead of joining the hunt he elects to get back to his family. Then he's not really given the choice once once the events in Hawaii happen. While I admit the whole thing with the kid is a little short and could have been better showing that he can still speak broken Japanese and that he hasn't completely buried his past. That would have been a great scene but we didn't get it. G-man throws down with the MUTO and it's off to San Francisco. At this point he's too deep and we get to see soldier Ford. He's serious about his job and he's good at it. He makes a mistake telling Elle to stay put with his son as he thinks he'll beat the MUTO's and Godzilla there to get them out because of the train. This fails and while he knows his son is safe he continues to ask for his wife. At this point he may think she's dead we don't know. Then to serve his country he embarks on the mission into the city.

I have a great memory don't I? Now that's not the point of that WALL OF TEXT, just being dramatic there. As an amateur writer seeing the beats of story is becoming more easy for me. Again I would have liked to see more growth from Ford, but I don't think that was the point of the story being told. The story was of an ordinary man in an extraordinary situation. I'm no soldier, but put in that same situation would I have reacted differently? I don't know and I think that's the beauty of Fords character. We can see ourselves in him. He is relate-able enough that we can sympathize with him within the story that he is placed into. Compare this if you would to Ian Malcolm in Jurassic Park he doesn't change at all in the movie. We meet him as a snarky mathematician and that's how he ends the movie. That's very similar to Ford, we meet him as a soldier/family man with an estranged father and he ends the movie basically the same. And people love Ian Malcolm. So while I agree more character development would have been good, I can't say he sucks because in my opinion he doesn't. Thanks for reading

Join the discussion!



Latest Media
Community Stats
This Godzilla Movie community is part of the Scified network. Scified hosts a network of online fan-site communities containing 406,397 posts by 48,447 members (23 are online now). The Shin-Gojira Forum is the most recently active forum. The latest Forum topic added was: Saw the 4K remaster of Shin Godzilla in theatres! Makes me want a sequel.
VIPWhat are VIP?AdminModeratorSpecial TitleMember
Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoScified is the Hub for Sci-Fi Movie Fandoms
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
GodzillaFansite
PredatorFansite
Main Menu
Community
Sci-Fi Movies
Help & Info
+

Sign In to contribute!